Celebrity Justice
Anna Nicole to E!: You Screwed Me

The new E! show "Pop Fiction" sounds like a complete rip off of another pitch -- "Celebrities Strike Back." Oh, by the way -- it was pitched by Anna Nicole Smith more than three years ago and there could be a lawsuit.
Read the treatment
"Pop Fiction," produced by Ashton Kutcher's Katalyst Television, debuted last night. It seems identical to a treatment obtained by TMZ that Anna Nicole registered with the Writers Guild in 2004. Now get this -- in 2004, Anna Nicole and Howard K. Stern met with Jeff Shore and Jay James, both programming execs for E!. They pitched the show and sent Shore the treatment.

We're also told Anna Nicole and Howard K. met with then E! Prez Ted Harbert in 2004 and also raised the show.

Ashton's show sounds like a carbon of Anna's treatment -- "...what happens if Anna Nicole Smith and other celebrities turn the tables and capitalize off of the overzealous media? What if the next big supposed scandal is not a scandal at all? What if everything is staged, but the media (and the public) don't know it?" It continues, Anna Nicole and other celebrity guests take aim at the media and push all the limits."

That's Ashton Kutcher's show and we're told Howard K. has already threatened suit. What is really pissing him off is that he and Anna had multiple meetings with E!. Two months ago, Stern spoke with E! again on behalf of the estate and the network seemed intrigued by making Larry Birkhead the celeb to do the first prank and then host the show. Ultimately Jay James said it just wouldn't work. Oh really?

UPDATE: A rep for E! tells us, "'Pop Fiction' is a program independently created and developed by Ashton Kutcher's company, Katalyst. 'Pop Fiction' is not based on any idea or concept that may have been pitched to E! by any other party."

Reader Comments

(Page 6 of 10) Previous 15 Comments | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

76. 59. Guess the only made sure she was drugged when she was in front of the camera, during interviews and at award shows.
Who keeps pharmacy sizes methodone in their refrigerator?

Posted at 4:13PM on Mar 10th 2008 by She was an addict - face it

A person that is in recovery and happens to be in a country that doesn't have a Methadone Maintenance program. At least she was on Methadone and not Oxycontin or Vicodin.

Posted at 7:21PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Peppermint

77. Sorry #68 Andrea, the numbers must have changed cuz that was to #67 Shame on the Antinoids. Not directed to you or your comment. Peace

Posted at 7:21PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Kikoke

78. A person that is in recovery and happens to be in a country that doesn't have a Methadone Maintenance program. At least she was on Methadone and not Oxycontin or Vicodin.

Posted at 7:21PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Peppermint

Thank you, you helped reinforce my point - she was an A-D-D-I-C-T!

Posted at 7:53PM on Mar 10th 2008 by She was an addict - face it

79. 67. For you idiots out there that can not think on your own, Howard will not have to sue but the Writer's Guild will and can.

As we can see it was Anna's idea and why should she not get the credit. It is in black and white.

I would say this is a good law suit and any of you would do the same thing if this was you.

http://www.screenwritersfederation.org/copyright.asp#12

Posted at 5:19PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Shame on the Antinoids

Do you really think they give a rats ass about ANS and especially HKS?

Posted at 7:53PM on Mar 10th 2008 by too funny

80. At least she was on Methadone and not Oxycontin or Vicodin.

Posted at 7:21PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Peppermint

That we know of and it wouldn't surprise me.

Posted at 8:04PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Ms. Kitty

81. Howard - do you think we really care? Can't wait to see what unGodly amount you sue for. I bet it's not less than 8 digits. I don't think you're going to garner much sympathy from the general public.

Posted at 8:20PM on Mar 10th 2008 by cry me a river

82. When HKS asked LB to bend over, it appears LB happily obliged.
I'm still waiting for the pap's to snap a photo of LB with his boyfriend... Just wait, it will happen. Larry's being real careful right now.

Posted at 12:09AM on Mar 11th 2008 by that'll be the day

83. A person that is in recovery and happens to be in a country that doesn't have a Methadone Maintenance program. At least she was on Methadone and not Oxycontin or Vicodin.

Posted at 7:21PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Peppermint

LOL, I know isn't that something? Oops, guess what......she DIED! Guess it does not matter what she was on now!

Posted at 8:29PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Must Have Been Peppermint Schnapps

84. 81. At least she was on Methadone and not Oxycontin or Vicodin.

Posted at 7:21PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Peppermint

That we know of and it wouldn't surprise me.

Posted at 8:04PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Ms. Kitty




Does it matter???? She died!!!

Posted at 8:31PM on Mar 10th 2008 by !!!

85. Hey Howie baby, you going to be suing for 8 or 9 digits? What prestigeous attorney are you going to hire for this one?
Don't think you're going to get much support and or sympathy from the general public. The majority of us have figured out your game.

Posted at 8:37PM on Mar 10th 2008 by grow some character

86. See like I always thought Anna Nicole was a smart cookie .
I only wish she were still alive.
Boy... wouldn't that be something..........
I have always thought an idea like this show would be great myself.
Some of the media deserves to be punked for going too far.

Posted at 8:57PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Dawnn

87. Script protection:
http://www.screenwritersfederation.org/copyright.asp#12

What is the registration fee and how long is my work registered?
Our $18.95 fee is for ten-year registration. We accept Mastercard, Visa & American Express and use secure servers to protect your privacy. At any time in the registration period, you can renew for an additional ten-year term by mailing us the appropriate fee. Renewals are accepted up to one-month prior to expiration. At the time of registration, you authorize National Creative Registry to destroy your file without further notice to you on the expiration date in the event you choose not to renew. ProtectRite does not make comparisons of registration submissions or give any legal advice or confer any statutory protections.

How does ProtectRite compare to the Writer's Guild registration?
ProtectRite offers the exact same protection as the Writer's Guild registration service for less money and longer terms. $18.95 for ten-year registration as opposed to $20 for five-year registration.


The major question for me is: Does this registration expire when some one dies?

Posted at 8:41PM on Mar 10th 2008 by script protection

88. test

Posted at 8:46PM on Mar 10th 2008 by test

89. 85. 81. At least she was on Methadone and not Oxycontin or Vicodin.

Posted at 7:21PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Peppermint

That we know of and it wouldn't surprise me.

Posted at 8:04PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Ms. Kitty

I'm sure she had a wide selection in the duffel bag o' drugs. Isn't that right Howard?

Posted at 8:53PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Things that make u go hmmm...

90. 87. Script protection:
http://www.screenwritersfederation.org/copyright.asp#12

What is the registration fee and how long is my work registered?
Our $18.95 fee is for ten-year registration. We accept Mastercard, Visa & American Express and use secure servers to protect your privacy. At any time in the registration period, you can renew for an additional ten-year term by mailing us the appropriate fee. Renewals are accepted up to one-month prior to expiration. At the time of registration, you authorize National Creative Registry to destroy your file without further notice to you on the expiration date in the event you choose not to renew. ProtectRite does not make comparisons of registration submissions or give any legal advice or confer any statutory protections.

How does ProtectRite compare to the Writer's Guild registration?
ProtectRite offers the exact same protection as the Writer's Guild registration service for less money and longer terms. $18.95 for ten-year registration as opposed to $20 for five-year registration.


The major question for me is: Does this registration expire when some one dies?

Posted at 8:41PM on Mar 10th 2008 by script protection

*************************************************************************
The co-author is not dead.

Posted at 8:51PM on Mar 10th 2008 by Bai

Previous 15 Comments | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments